France’s ‘Yellow Vests’: A movement of many shades


France’s ‘Yellow Vests’: A movement of many shades

Pensioners, health workers, anti-capitalists, gardeners, business owners - all mobilising against Macron's government


France’s “Yellow Vests” protesters are all angry at President Emmanuel Macron, but their different goals and grievances show how diverse the movement has become.
Protesters turning out across France on Saturday highlighted demands ranging from better support for pensioners to the downfall of capitalism.
Jobless millennial, unemployed waiter Tim Viteau, 29, and his girlfriend are planning to move back in with their parents because they cannot pay their rent.
“It’s as if we’re 16 years old,” said Viteau, who hitched a lift from the eastern city of Lyon for his third Parisian demonstration in as many weeks.
“I’m on benefits, the biggest business in France,” he joked.
Striking up conversation with a couple of fellow twenty-somethings, he asked them: “How do you manage to have children? I also want to have children, but I cannot plan beyond the next four months.”
Cash-strapped pensioner Sylvia Paloma was among about 2,000 protesters marching through the southern port city of Marseille. Like many senior citizens who have joined the movement, the 70-year-old is angry at Macron’s government for squeezing her allowances.
“To get to our age and have to beg, it’s mad,” the former civil servant said.
With a traditional French revolutionary cap on her head, she had the words “Macron, resign, don’t be dumb” emblazoned on the back of her luminous vest.
“This is the first time I’ve ever protested,” Paloma said. “I get a pension of €1,248 (R20,000) a month, my four children have to help me out.”
Hubert Bertrand, 53, owns a small construction company and says the tax and social security bills in France, among the highest in Europe, leave him unable to give his staff a pay rise.
“Our leaders are completely detached from reality,” he said at the Marseille protest. “We should have entrepreneurs, shopkeepers and artisans running the country.”
Bertrand has abstained in recent elections or ruined his ballot.
“Misery is seeping out of Paris,” sang anti-capitalist activist Alice, who declined to give her last name. “This isn’t a government problem, it’s a problem with a political system which is capitalist and liberal,” the 31-year-old said.
Her group was marching with a black and red anarchist flag and a banner that read: “Social justice or total war.”
Alice, who works as a summer camp coordinator, is not bothered by the fact that the “Yellow Vests” movement spans from the far-left to the far-right. “We don’t care if you’re left or right,” she said. “The question is how to build a political movement for all citizens out of this. We need unions to call a general strike.”
Lydie Bailly, a 48-year-old health worker, is among many “Yellow Vests” who thinks Macron understands little of the lives of ordinary people.
“We haven’t had a pay rise in 10 years, it’s just disgusting. We’re not even scraping by, it’s just not possible anymore,” she said.
A matter of extravagance
It isn’t just Macron’s former life as an investment banker that raises the ire of protesters, or a string of comments he’s made which have been deemed dismissive of the working classes. Many protesters cite an order for a new set of china for the Elysee Palace for a reported €500,000 as evidence of his personal extravagance.
Bailly wants a leader more like Germany’s Angela Merkel, who lives in an ordinary apartment in Berlin. “She takes the train and regular planes, not private jets,” Bailly said.
Thomas Lefeuvre, 24, represents a small sub-section of the movement who would like to see France do away with parliamentary democracy altogether.
A gardener by trade, Lefeuvre was protesting with a bunch of flowers in his hands, “in homage to the peaceful warriors in Paris today”.
“We want citizens’ referenda,” said the father of one, who, like many other “Yellow Vests” says he struggles to make ends meet on his salary of 1,300 euros a month.
“With the internet, we don’t need members of parliament anymore. We can vote for everything by referendum,” he said.

This article is reserved for Times Select subscribers.
A subscription gives you full digital access to all Times Select content.

Times Select

Already subscribed? Simply sign in below.

Questions or problems?
Email or call 0860 52 52 00.