That’s my monarchy! Noble sues France for Monaco throne


That’s my monarchy! Noble sues France for Monaco throne

Aristocrat says a bit of royal wrangling 100 years ago robbed his family of their right to rule

Rory Mulholland

An aristocrat is suing France for £314m in damages allegedly for depriving his family of the throne of Monaco to stop it falling into the hands of a German in 1911.
Louis de Causans says that in the early 20th century France threatened to annex the principality if it did not change its rules of succession. Monaco complied, depriving De Causans’s branch of the family of his birthright and giving control to another offshoot of the Grimaldi family.
“Normally, in my milieu, we remain discreet and we don’t like to stir up this sort of thing. But the truth must be established. It is a question of honour,” said De Causans, whose full name is Louis Jean Raymond Marie de Vincent de Causans.
But he insisted he was not aiming to dethrone Prince Albert, his cousin, the current ruler of the principality and head of the princely house of Grimaldi, despite the fact that he believes his own uncle should be on the throne today.
“I have nothing against Prince Albert, who had nothing to do with all of this. It is France that caused the damage,” the 44-year-old told Le Parisien.
The dispute dates to just more than a century ago when Prince Louis II of Monaco had no official heir. This meant that the next in line for the throne of Monaco was his first cousin, Wilhelm, the Duke of Urach, a German nobleman.
“But for France, on the brink of world war, the idea of a German ruling Monaco was simply unacceptable,” said Jean-Marc Descoubes, De Causans’s lawyer.
The throne should then have passed to De Causans’s branch of the Grimaldi family, the aristocrat argued. Instead, a law was passed in 1911 recognising Louis’s illegitimate daughter, Charlotte, the daughter of Marie-Juliette Louvet, his cabaret-singer lover, as his heir, making her part of the princely family.
This law was later declared invalid but another one was passed in 1918 that established Charlotte as heir.
France and Monaco signed a treaty that stated the French government would henceforth have the final say on all future contenders for the Monégasque throne.
De Causans’s lawyer says it is clear that the current rulers of Monaco are in position solely through the will of the French state. This forms the basis of his claim for the damages to which he believes his client is entitled. He points out that this is a mere fraction of the wealth of the Grimaldis who rule Monaco.
He has sent his claim to the French foreign ministry, which has two months to respond. If no satisfactory response is received within that time, the case will probably go to court.
“Today, what I want is for the truth to come out and this injustice done to my family by France to be put right,” said De Causans.
– © The Daily Telegraph

This article is reserved for Times Select subscribers.
A subscription gives you full digital access to all Times Select content.

Times Select

Already subscribed? Simply sign in below.

Questions or problems?
Email or call 0860 52 52 00.