‘I quit law the day an accused offered his gold tooth as payment’
Academic’s anecdote highlights impact of court delays, expenses on the poor
An accused shoplifter’s offer to pay legal fees with his gold tooth prompted an enthusiastic lawyer to quit the profession.
Now a Nelson Mandela University law academic, Tina Hokwana recently recalled her experience.
“I knew I was done litigating in criminal court the day an accused took out his gold tooth as payment for my fees,” she posted on Twitter.
Other Twitter users responded by also sharing their experiences.
I knew I was done litigating in criminal court the day an accused took out his gold tooth as payment for my fees.— Tina (@Tina_Hokwana) April 26, 2021
“A client came with a dispute concerning ownership of a piece of land. Payment? He’d give us the said land if he won the case,” Takondwera responded.
“The grandmother of a client offered homemade bottled fruit as part of fee payment,” said JoeJoe.
Another Twitter user, Ntsieni Mudzielwana Murwa waha Tshikovhangamakamba, said she thought it was “my profession only whereby people opt for anything as payment. I once was told to sell debris as payment to neighbours building their mansion with not enough material to fill the foundation.”
@Oumuamua posted: “I had a tenant that worked for Nike years ago — wanted to pay me in takkies. I told him if he could deposit it into my bank account, I would be OK with it.”
Hokwana spoke to Sunday Times Daily on Thursday. She said her tweet was prompted by a recent visit to a Port Elizabeth court to see a friend.
A client came with a dispute concerning ownership of a piece of land. Payment? He'd give us the said land if he won the case.— Takondwera (@_takondwa) April 26, 2021
“I haven’t been to court in a while and the week before I had to meet a friend at the criminal court. I had all the flashes of my previous appearances in court flooding back. And that morning I just remembered this is the reason why I don’t appear in court any more. It was just too stressful for me. I decided to join academia,” said Hokwana.
Hokwana had been practising for five years, including two years of articles, when she was approached by a man accused of shoplifting who asked her to represent him. The man was unemployed and the only valuable item he could think of was his gold tooth.
“I was going to appear in about three or four courts that day, so I had a matter at criminal court, I had a matter in maintenance court, I had a matter in civil court and I think I had debt review case that I also had. So I asked for the matter to stand down for me to be able to speak to him,” she said.
“I was able to get some sort of background into his case and his financial situation. At the time, he was unemployed. His matter had been postponed numerous times.
The grandmother of a client offered home made bottled fruit as part of fee payment. 🤦— Joejoe (@Joejoe33473115) April 26, 2021
“He did not trust his Legal Aid attorneys. So there was just a lot that was going on with him. He then approached me to see if I would be able to make the same request to the magistrate and the state for the charges to be provisionally withdrawn until such time that the state was ready to proceed.
“But at the time, he was not a client of mine and there was a process in my law firm that all clients must sign a service-level agreement that a deposit must be paid. A client had to go through all those steps before I could represent him.”
Hokwana said she spoke to the prosecutor and asked that the matter be stood down so that she could take instructions.
I thought is my profession only whereby people opt for anything as payment. I once was told to sell debris as payment to neighbors building their mansion with no enough material to fill the foundation. pic.twitter.com/tSLyXKzEta— Ntsieni Mudzielwana Murwa waha Tshikovhangamakamba (@NtsieniUnaado) April 26, 2021
“The only way I could be able to deal with the matter would be to try to find an attorney who specialises in criminal law because at the time I was not specialising in criminal law. It was an area of law I was not interested in. I just happened to have criminal law clients and I was the only one in my firm that had criminal law experience,” she said.
“I was able to find a friend of mine who specialised in criminal law and was able to make representations after proper consultation to be able to present argument in court for the charges to be withdrawn.
“It was a sad reality of the state of people going through the justice system because there is no reason why a charge of shoplifting should be postponed for five, six times. There is no reason for an accused to be denied bail for shoplifting.
“This is a person who is unemployed and our criminal justice system is expecting that person to be at court every single time — only for the matter to be postponed.”
Hokwana said she became very emotional when the accused offered to take out his tooth and offer it to her as payment.
“I said: ‘You can keep it.’
“I think it was one of those detachable ones and he said he had paid — while he was still working — R2,500 for it to be inserted.
“When a person in that position is in financial distress, you do not take what they have or what they see as something of value.
“All I could do for him was to find a friend who specialises in criminal law to take the matter pro bono [for free] as he could not afford legal representation.”