Height of madness: racist Vicki Momberg cries insanity

News

Height of madness: racist Vicki Momberg cries insanity

She plans to tell the court she suffered 'temporary non-pathological incapacity' when using the k-word over 40 times

Journalist

Convicted of repeatedly injuring the dignity of black police officials in a foul-mouthed racist rant – and sentenced to a landmark two-year jail term – estate agent Vicki Momberg is set to make legal history yet again.
She’s won the right to appeal both her conviction and sentence in the Johannesburg High Court, meaning that, once this case is decided by that court, it will set a precedent for sentencing in other crimen injuria cases.
But Momberg will also tread new legal ground in terms of her conviction appeal. She will argue that she was wrongly convicted because she was temporarily insane when she used the k-word more than 40 times, marking the first time that temporary insanity has been used to defend racist language in the high court.
As a result of this appeal, the Momberg case could set a precedent not only for the sentencing of people who use racist slurs, but also for the kinds of defences they may raise to explain their conduct.
Momberg has already served five months of her effective two-year jail term, and should be released on parole in the coming months.She will, however, return to the Randburg Magistrate’s Court on Thursday to argue that she should be granted bail pending the outcome of her appeal. Magistrate Pravina Raghoonandan had refused Momberg leave to appeal her conviction and sentence in April this year, but her lawyers successfully petitioned the high court.
Momberg was caught on camera racially abusing a black police officer after she was a victim of a smash-and-grab incident. The video went viral and, while Momberg later sought to suggest that it may have been tampered with, it provided overwhelming evidence of her guilt.
During her trial, Momberg sought to suggest that she was so overwhelmed by the trauma of the attack that she suffered from “temporary non-pathological incapacity” – or temporary insanity – and could therefore not be held fully accountable for her actions.The state, represented by advocate Yusuf Baba, believes this defence is the first time that temporary insanity has been used to avoid criminal liability for racism.
This type of temporary insanity defence is typically used in intimate femicide murder cases, where a man accused of murdering his female partner will argue that he attacked her after experiencing extreme emotion or stress and then “losing control”.
Temporary pathological incapacity is also used as a defence in “road rage” murder cases. Momberg’s temporary insanity defence, therefore, appears to be legally novel.

This article is reserved for Times Select subscribers.
A subscription gives you full digital access to all Times Select content.

Times Select

Already subscribed? Simply sign in below.

Questions or problems?
Email helpdesk@timeslive.co.za or call 0860 52 52 00.

Previous Article