Leadership, accountability needed to pull SA hospitals from the brink
Water outages, power cuts, neglect and criminality are taking their toll on SA’s healthcare facilities
A fire at one of the biggest public hospitals in Johannesburg, the Charlotte Maxeke Johannesburg Academic Hospital, and the delay in reopening the facility has brought infrastructural issues into sharp focus. The fire broke out in mid-April. Only now is a phased reopening of the facility being undertaken.
Reopening was delayed due to safety issues. A host of compliance measures weren’t in place. These included fire hydrants without a water supply, fire hydrants without correct couplings, non-functional fire doors and a lack of emergency lighting in the stairwells. These deficiencies had been long-standing.
I am extremely familiar with conditions on the ground in hospitals in the area. I interact daily with doctors and students in the different academic hospitals on the circuit of the University of the Witwatersrand (Wits) in Johannesburg. These include the Charlotte Maxeke Johannesburg Academic Hospital, Chris Hani Baragwanath Academic Hospital, Helen Joseph Hospital and Rahima Moosa Mother and Child Hospital. I also visit different institutions in the region.
I completed my undergraduate and postgraduate training at these hospitals and worked for more than 30 years in the neonatal-paediatric intensive care unit and neonatal unit at Charlotte Maxeke Johannesburg Academic Hospital.
During this time I’ve observed many changes in the healthcare sector in general and in these hospitals in particular.
SA’s healthcare system compares favourably on a global level. The medical schools of the University of the Witwatersrand and the University of Cape Town (UCT) are ranked in the top 100 in the world. Over the years the region has produced many eminent healthcare workers. And the country is quite capable of delivering world-class healthcare to all its citizens.
But this is constantly being hampered by an increasingly unconducive environment.
The public sector hospitals in Gauteng are generally in bad condition. Chris Hani Baragwanath Academic Hospital is the third largest in the world, with almost 3,200 beds and more than 6,000 staff. Charlotte Maxeke Johannesburg Academic Hospital has 1,088 beds and more than 4,000 staff.
These large public sector hospitals provide tertiary and quaternary services to more than 250,000 inpatients and almost one million outpatients every year.
Most were built more than 50 years ago and have been poorly maintained. The crumbling infrastructure results in flooding, sewage leaks, lack of water, problems with the supply of medical air and oxygen, and electricity blackouts. Leaky plumbing creates a damp environment that favours pests such as cockroaches and rodents. Inadequate airconditioning results in working conditions that are unbearably hot or freezing cold. Both are harmful to patients.
Doctors and nurses have to deal with a shortage of hospital beds on a daily basis.
Gauteng provides healthcare to many patients from other provinces, as well as surrounding countries, particularly Zimbabwe. The provinces of North West and Mpumalanga do not have medical schools and therefore send patients for specialised tertiary and quaternary care, such as cardiothoracic surgery and renal dialysis, to the Gauteng academic hospitals.
In addition, under-resourced regional and district hospitals result in primary and secondary patients receiving treatment in the tertiary or quaternary institutions because there is nowhere else for them to go.
Overcrowding and infrastructural issues negatively affect patient care. Hospital-acquired infections with “super bugs” resistant to almost all known antibiotics are a major health challenge. Sewage leaks and inadequate plumbing increase the risk of infections.
Ongoing power cuts and water shortages compound the internal infrastructural issues at each hospital. There have been rolling electricity blackouts in the country as the government struggles to keep Eskom operational.
Each hospital has a diesel generator. But this emergency backup does not always kick in during blackouts and load-shedding. Patients in intensive care and the operating theatre are particularly at risk.
Water infrastructure, which has not been maintained by local authorities, is in a state of disrepair resulting in a growing number of water outages. In recent weeks, three of the largest hospitals in the province — Helen Joseph, Rahima Moosa and Chris Hani Baragwanath — all experienced a water outage that lasted several days.
Surgeons were scrubbing for theatre using buckets, people could not flush toilets and patients were issued with bottled water and could not wash.
On top of all this, the Covid-19 pandemic is now raging in the province. This is proving to be the last straw for a buckling health system. Shortages of hospital beds, lack of oxygen supplies, inadequate ICU facilities are a few of the problems being faced.
Healthcare workers are exhausted and burnt out.
How it got to this
There are multiple reasons for the current debacle. These include a lack of preventive maintenance, poor administration, corruption, poor forward planning, lack of financial resources and a lack of strong governance at municipal and provincial level.
The governance of the hospitals is complex and falls between different government departments. The department of infrastructure and development, or public works, has been tasked by the department of health to take care of hospital infrastructure. This means a hospital CEO isn’t directly responsible for maintenance of the building.
It's a fallacy that SA has two healthcare systems. The country has one – the public academic institutions train the healthcare workers who work in the private and public sector. If the public healthcare sector collapses, the private sector will follow.
In turn this means the system for responding to maintenance issues is not agile.
Bureaucratic processes designed to minimise corruption result in long delays. Management at all levels tends to put out fires rather than implement a long-term strategy to improve the situation.
Facilities have also been affected by strikes about wage disputes. In some cases hospital facilities have been damaged during industrial action.
Criminality is also a problem. Theft is common, with wall mirrors, bathroom tiles, soft furnishings, even large potted plants disappearing. Most recently copper plumbing pipes were stolen from Charlotte Maxeke hospital while it stood empty.
The fallacy that SA has two healthcare systems
There is a perception of an “us and them” among many South Africans. People with medical aid feel relieved that they have access to private healthcare, which does not have all these problems.
This is a fallacy. The country has one healthcare system — the public academic institutions train the healthcare workers who work in the private and public sector. If the public healthcare sector collapses, the private sector will follow.
The solution is proper management and accountability at all levels. SA spends enough money on healthcare (just over 10% of GDP), but there is terrible waste at many levels. The government is pursuing a National Health Insurance (NHS) scheme, with the aim of pooling resources to provide “quality affordable personal health services for all South Africans, based on health needs, not socio-economic status”.
If implemented and governed properly, the new scheme is most likely the best solution to all the many problems facing the country’s healthcare system. And it will allow SA to reach its full potential of providing excellent healthcare to all.
Prof Daynia Ballot is head of the School of Clinical Medicine at the University of the Witwatersrand
This article was first published by The Conversation.